I have been seeing TV commercials for the new Ender’s Game movie and I have to admit, the first time I saw one I kind of groaned a little and thought, “Why that book?” But after seeing a few more of the commercials I’m starting to think it does look good.
It’s strange… I had actually forgotten that I liked Ender’s Game. (the first book) I read, I think, the first four books in the series and I think maybe I should have quit with just one, or maybe two. Right now I can’t even remember much about the later books but I have this impression in my mind of them being overwhelmingly dreary and that’s what I thought of when I first learned about the movie.
By the way, I know some people have such a problem with Orson Scott Card’s politics that they won’t read his books. That sort of thing usually doesn’t bother me. As long as the politics doesn’t completely overwhelm the story I don’t much care what goes on in the author’s mind. Sometimes I would rather not know but talent is not limited to those we agree with.
Anyway, this movie – I do want to see it but it is far from being the first movie I would have chosen if it had been up to me to decide, “Which science fiction book should we make a movie of next?” When this subject comes up between my sons and I Neal Asher’s books are at the top of our list, along with Larry Niven’s Ringworld. I understand there has been talk of a Ringworld movie for decades. Now it looks like there might be a Mini-series on SyFy but I am inclined to be skeptical until I actually see it.
I’m not sure though, whether any of those would be my first choice if I really thought about it. I don’t normally read a good book and think, “This needs to be a movie.” I’m perfectly happy with books being books, but it’s true that some books have the potential to be great movies. Looking at my bookshelves, Lucifer’s Hammer sort of leaps out at me. Then I think of Ben Bova’s Grand Tour novels. (some of which are better than others) And Jack Chalker’s Well World books could be a great, quirky TV series. It seems too much for just a movie.
So, science fiction fans, what book(s) would you like to see as movies?