Violins and Starships

Thoughts on Dr Who

May 21st, 2008

Andrea has an entertaining review of the current season of Dr. Who. I guess I have to admit she’s right about most of that but I love the show anyway. Maybe it’s the British accents.

I actually know nothing about British culture except for what I have learned from movies, TV and of course the Internet where they don’t have any accents at all and seem almost indistinguishable from Americans except for when they start talking about strange sports like soccer and cricket so I want to make it clear that when I say I love British culture I have no idea what I’m talking about. Whatever I see on Dr. Who that is ridiculous and unbelievable way beyond any possible “willing suspension of disbelief,” I just tend to put down as more charming British weirdness and I love it.

So far I’m not totally charmed by Donna, The Doctor’s current companion. I don’t dislike her at all but I don’t like her as well as either Rose or Martha. Martha returned in the latest episode and we caught a quick glimpse of Rose in another episode this season. It’s sort of annoying that they haven’t gone anywhere with that yet – just that little surprise, which leads you to expect something, and then on to other, unrelated things.

Unlike Andrea, I liked the sad captive Ood song. On the other hand, I hated the, “Ood are so trusting because they carry their brains in their hands” bit. Oh come on! That almost goes beyond what can be excused as “just more charming British weirdness.” Also I’m getting tired of the – I can’t remember what they’re called – the green aliens who disguise themselves as humans and unzip their human suits at the forehead when they want to freak someone out. They’re gross and disgusting and neither funny nor scary.

Mostly though, I love Dr. Who. I can hardly wait for the next episode.

One Response to “Thoughts on Dr Who

  1. Andrea Harris

    Well actually I love Doctor Who too. But I also love to nitpick and criticize, and it’s good for the brain to criticize things you love anyway. (For instance, Lord of the Rings is my favorite book, but… no, that comment would be too long.)

    I do agree the whole concept of the Oods carrying part of their brain in their hands is ludicrous — I mean, how do they fend for themselves if they have only one usable hand? Wouldn’t their culture have developed special protective brain-carriers that they could, say, wear around their necks, thus both freeing up their other hand and giving their brain part extra protection? And come to think of it, it’s not necessarily true that carrying part of their brains in their hands would make them more trusting. I know it would make me more paranoid and fearful — I’d always be worried about dropping it, birds crapping on it, people bumping into me, and the fact that lopping this part off makes the Oods capable of being enslaved surely would have been exploited by evil fellow Oods long before humans came upon them. Then again they have that whole “hive mind” thing which might stop that sort of behavior….

    I’m going to stop now.

Proudly powered by WordPress. Theme developed with WordPress Theme Generator.
Copyright © Violins and Starships. All rights reserved.