Violins and Starships

Opera and Athleticism

September 29th, 2008

Here is an article from 1979 that I wish everyone, especially opera haters, would read.

Opera singers, athletes? Those paranoid, overpampered, overweight bags of air who won’t go outside for fear of catching a cold, who speak in monosyllables for fear of tiring their voices, who flee the room when someone takes out a cigarette? Dancers, yes, now they could be called athletes. After all, they move around, they even pick people up. But singers?

People speak of a singer’s musicality, his subtle phrasing, his feeling for a song. Never do they mention his athletic ability. And even when they speak of a singer’s power, they don’t usually equate it with physical strength. But the fact is, opera is extremely demanding physically, and a good opera singer must possess many of the same qualities as other good athletes: strength, coordination, stamina. His playing field may be a stage, his uniform a fancy costume and his warmup suit a five-foot scarf, but a singer is, in his way, as much an athlete as Terry Bradshaw or Reggie Jackson.

The article goes into quite a bit of detail about the physical demands of operatic singing. Again, I wish everyone in the world would read this. Honestly, I don’t expect everyone to like opera. Different strokes for different folks as they say. But when people dismiss opera as “nothing but a lot of screaming and bellowing” that is just as wrong, fundamentally dishonest and inexcusable as it would be if I said baseball players are not athletes because they spend a lot of time just standing around. You can recognize the skill and talent even if you don’t like the end result.

One Response to “Opera and Athleticism”

  1. fillyjonk

    I had a friend who had some minor respiratory issues (that were related to muscle weakness, I guess). Her doctor suggested that she could try joining a choir as a way of strengthening her “pipes.” It worked…and she was able to avoid going on meds.

    I don’t doubt that singing opera takes considerable strength and stamina.

    I’ve also read about the high longevity of conductors and pianists and I think only part of that is that they’re doing something they love and that matters…I think all the arm motion must do something good for the heart.

Proudly powered by WordPress. Theme developed with WordPress Theme Generator.
Copyright © Violins and Starships. All rights reserved.